pull down to refresh
Yeah, it’s weird — on paper people gained equity, but in reality higher financing costs killed mobility. Cheap mortgages became golden handcuffs.
There really should be a second-hand mortgage matching market, so those of us in these situations can just swap mortgages with each other.
@SimpleStacker, do you know why that doesn't exist?
Good question, I'd have to think about that some more. A mortgage's terms and pricing are tied to the underlying quality of the collateral and the borrower, so I'm not sure how easy it would be to build some kind of swap market.
There's already a secondary market for mortgages in the sense of investors buying the loans from each other. But i've never heard of or thought about a market where borrowers can exchange their loan terms with each other.
Yeah, the problem is that the deal is with a particular borrower and there's a good chance one of the banks would prefer their current borrower to the new one.
Obviously, we could just move into each others' homes and do an informal swap, but that creates the same kind of incentive problem as renting.
Hmm, I got curious and asked AI about this. I actually started with something simpler than what you proposed:
"Are there mortgages where I can keep the terms of the loan while moving to a new house? There seem to be gains from trade to be had with the existing investor (I pay a slightly higher rate, though still not market rate; they let me switch the underlying collateral)."
Claude told me that what I'm describing is a portable mortgage, which does not exist in the US but does in Canada and the UK.
Claude told me that some mortgages in the US are assumable mortgages, which means that a new buyer can assume the terms of your loan when you sell it to them.
Neither is quite what you described, but have a similar flavor of reducing mortgage lock-in.
It sounds like two people with assumable mortgages could basically execute a swap.
That actually sounds like a brilliant idea. A second-hand mortgage market could solve a lot of the “golden handcuffs” problem and help people move without resetting to brutal current rates.
Yes, it's rather obnoxious for those of us with old cheap mortgages who would be interested in moving.
We accumulated some nice equity but can't afford to even make lateral moves.